Why I Am Not a Hindu has ratings and 21 reviews. Priya said: Casteism is an evil that has been prevalent in our country for ages though this has most. 6 Apr WHY I AM NOT A HINDU, A SUDRA CRITIQUE OF HINDUTVA, PHILOSOPHYM CULTURE AND POLITICAL ECONOMY. 19 Apr Who – or what – is a Hindu? There are no easy answers to this question. From the Oxford English Dictionary: Hinduism: A major religious and.

Author: Vizilkree Mikadal
Country: Libya
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Photos
Published (Last): 2 September 2014
Pages: 32
PDF File Size: 17.47 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.56 Mb
ISBN: 798-7-92814-523-1
Downloads: 46208
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Zolokasa

But back to the real world. While the oppression of dalitbahujan is ubiquitous, there is such geographical variation across India particularly wrt to the North South divide in how caste and gender are understood that such generalizations are meaningless. A must read for every hindu. All these tasks involve both mental and physical labour. Of course, there are poor Brahmins and other upper caste people who suffer real poverty.

If they are truly capable, why do these dumb-ed-kar worshippers beg for reservations? Rama killed ravana who was a dalit. You are free kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu call me anything you like. Some are extremely obvious and intuitive, some need some more analyses and introspection, some may be research level subjects where experts have differences.

The way he approaches the subject of the two cultures is anger-fueled to say the least and passionate at its best. Divide and rule policy.

Kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu am also sure that the same goes for many Brahmin members of the Congress and other secular parties. You gave too many stupid warnings, jail threats, even misquoted the constitution…spoke too much nonsense, and already got the wheel turning. Paul Krist that the purpose of this e-dialogue should be to know the vary views of different persons of different castesreligions and areas of our universe!

Am asking you to reply why you are not attacking Sikhism when it seems some of them are not treating you as an equal?

Why I Am Not a Hindu

It speaks of deep apathy a A radical take kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu caste, class, culture and religion from the viewpoint of oppressed classes. First of all,you denounce the rapistracist and fascist so called Gods,then you are welcome to this open discussion.


Do what you can to uplift yourselves and your community if you could. These so-called leaders and social reformers are only trying to perpetuate insecurities in dalits to benefit themselves.

Mesquiteice said September 19, So for example, if I claim that Z am a Prophet and only by believing what I blindly write on Agniveer. Why are you talking bad about freedom fighters? Particularly, this book shows the arrogance and the inherent fallacies of the steamrolling of culture under the grand Hindutva project.

There was lot of intermingling between these communities. I have always been on an equal footing with everyone.

They maintained huge stores of plant genes. It is neither a matter of pride nor a priviledge. Even today members of communities who have a steady and good source of income from traditional activities do not seek Education or Jobs.

More than a quarter of Dalits, mostly landless, get work for less than six months a year. The oven has to kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu heated to an exact temperature and the pots baked just long enough for them to become durable and yet retain their attractive colour.

Kancha Ilaiah on “Why I am not a Hindu” (From Stree Samya blog) | Jaya’s blog

My thoughts — based on personal experience — on the points summarized above. Kancha clearly exposes the hypocrisy of the Mahabharatha. A rich person is given kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu recognition and a poor person is not given due regards even in our religious bodies and places! This whole scheme is a specialized knowledge in itself.

The issue was deliberated at a length and after consideration it was unanimously approved that the two posts of English shall be re-advertised.

By the time India gained independence from Britain, “an all-India ‘upper’ caste elite – the new bhadralok the ‘upper’ caste combine – was ready to take over the whole range of post-colonial political institutions Post-independence, Brahmins and other upper-castes have retained power because of the educational advantage they wielded: History is usually written by and for the people in power; this treatise is kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu from a point of view of people who are a majority, but not in power.


This is deeply naive and trivializes the importance of gender as a lens with which to understand society. The brahminical economy even devalued production for the market and privileged its spiritual-mental labour over all other labour processes.

It speaks of deep apathy and disregard of the aspirations of Dalits. But dalits should realize that their birth religion is their true identity. Review up on my BLOG. If you are from the subcontinent you are likely stuck in a similar construct anyway.

He even attempts to explain Hindu sexism by proffering literary evidence tending to show how “all women, including Brahmin women, were treated in the same demeaning way because they were seen to share the same genealogical origins It is a constitutional mechanism.

I have interacted with many many brahmins and other so called upper caste and have never been discriminated or anything.

If only you can shoot arrows like eklavya….

Squibs™: Book review: Why I Am Not a Hindu

Whatever be the reason, nlt putting off of a potential sympathetic reader does not speak in support of the way the argument has been presented. How do we find the criminal? There is absolutely no element of birth-based discrimination or denial of opportunity for any human being in Vedic way of life. Because our gods kancha ilaiah why i am not a hindu what we dalit bahujans eat. I specifically enjoyed his criticism of conventional reading of the Ramayana and the inherently violent nature of many mainstream Hindu Gods.

For a more detailed analysis of less subtle extensions, read all the articles in http: